Upper eyelid surgery, or blepharoplasty, removes extra skin from the upper lids, either to clear the field of vision or for appearance. The incision usually sits in the natural lid crease and tends to heal well. Even so, many patients are told to buy silicone scar gels afterward, which can be expensive. A systematic review published in November 2026 in the journal Orbit asked whether the evidence supports that routine.
What the researchers did
Researchers in Brazil searched PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane for studies of topical silicone after upper blepharoplasty. Only three studies qualified, covering 472 patients and 944 eyelids. Because the studies were so different from one another, the authors summarized them in words rather than pooling the numbers.
What the three studies showed
- The strongest study, a randomized, double-blinded, split-face trial, found no clinical advantage of silicone gel over petrolatum ointment over six months for redness, raised scars, color change, or patient satisfaction.
- A second prospective study found that scars improved over time in every group, with silicone speeding contour improvement at three months.
- A retrospective study reported fewer later steroid injections with a multi-ingredient silicone cream, but the authors judged it at high risk of bias.
The authors’ conclusion
Current evidence does not show that topical silicone is clinically better than simpler, lower-cost options such as petrolatum for upper eyelid scars. They suggested that eyelid skin heals well because of its rich blood supply, and that keeping the wound moist and protected may matter more than silicone itself. They called for better randomized trials.
What this means if you are planning eyelid surgery
- Follow your surgeon’s aftercare instructions; they are tailored to your incision and skin.
- Ask what ointment is recommended and whether a costly scar product adds anything in your case.
- Protect healing skin from sun, and avoid rubbing or picking at the incision.
- Call your surgeon about increasing redness, swelling, discharge, or vision changes.
Eyelid surgery is performed by oculoplastic and facial plastic surgeons; if you are considering it, ask for a consultation with a board-certified oculoplastic surgeon. For more plain-language reading on eye health, see epilasikmd.com.
Source: Topical silicone for eyelid surgical scars: a systematic review of efficacy and clinical outcomes (Orbit (PubMed), 11/03/2026). This article is an educational summary written by Khanna Vision Institute and is not a substitute for medical advice.